Acceptability of Soy Milk as a Calcium-Rich Beverage in School Children in New York City Public Schools

Purpose

NYC Public Schools is testing offering soy milk alongside dairy milk on the lunch line for all students during the month of May at select school sites to understand: - Whether students choose and drink soy milk - Whether offering soy milk can reduce milk waste - The potential environmental, nutrition, and cost impacts

Condition

  • Food Acceptance

Eligibility

Eligible Ages
Between 5 Years and 18 Years
Eligible Sex
All
Accepts Healthy Volunteers
Yes

Inclusion Criteria

Students at the 11 participating New York City Public Schools that opted to join the pilot program and broader study. -

Exclusion Criteria

Students who don't want to try soymilk or have soy allergies are excluded. -

Study Design

Phase
Study Type
Observational
Observational Model
Ecologic or Community
Time Perspective
Other

Arm Groups

ArmDescriptionAssigned Intervention
Elementary, Middle and High School Kids The pilot will include a variety of elementary, middle, and high schools that opt into the program and they will be grades K-12 and ages 5-18.
  • Other: Acceptability of soy milk
    In the spring and fall of 2026, we aim to test the acceptability of soy milk over a four-week period of time in 11 New York City Public Schools. Leading up to the intervention, we will take baseline measurements of cow's milk, both sales and amount of beverage consumed. During the 4-week intervention, there will be taste tests at each school and measurements of consumption of both cow's milk and soy milk. At the end of the intervention, we will measure consumption of both cow's milk and soy milk.

Recruiting Locations

Maspeth
Elmhurst, New York 11373
Contact:
Nelson Quiles
7187074316
NQuiles@schools.nyc.gov

PS244
Flushing, New York 11355
Contact:
Nelson Quiles
7187074316
NQuiles@schools.nyc.gov

Beacon HS
New York, New York 10036
Contact:
Nelson Quiles
7187074316
NQuiles@schools.nyc.gov

PS16
Staten Island, New York 10301
Contact:
Nelson Quiles
7187074316
NQuiles@schools.nyc.gov

PS369
The Bronx, New York 10454
Contact:
Nelson Quiles
7187074316
NQuiles@schools.nyc.gov

Vertex Academy
The Bronx, New York 10472
Contact:
Nelson Quiles
7187074316
NQuiles@schools.nyc.gov

More Details

Status
Recruiting
Sponsor
Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine

Study Contact

Zeeshan Ali, PhD
202-527-7302
zali@PCRM.org

Detailed Description

Acceptability of Soy Milk as a Calcium-Rich Beverage in School Children in New York City Public Schools. The study intervention proposal: In the spring and fall of 2026, we aim to test the acceptability of soy milk over a four-week period of time in 11 New York City Public Schools. Leading up to the intervention, we will take baseline measurements of cow's milk, both sales and amount of beverage consumed. During the 4-week intervention, there will be taste tests at each school. At the end of the intervention, we will measure consumption of both cow's milk and soy milk. Students will be offered a sticker for tasting the soy milk and posters and other marketing materials will be utilized in schools. No information, identifiable or otherwise will be collected from the students. In addition to student acceptability, we aim to determine whether calcium was increased as a result of bringing soy milk into the lunch line. This is a replication of a study our team published April 2006 in the Journal of the AMERICAN DIETETIC ASSOCIATION. In coordination with the New York City Office of Food and Nutrition Services and non-profit partners, we will conduct a pilot with 11 schools to see how many students take soy milk, and to report on associated food waste. With the results, this will inform the school system with information about expanding access to soy milk and we aim to publish the results to inform other food service staff across the United States about the acceptability of soy milk in school lunch programs. The pilot will include a variety of elementary, middle, and high schools that opt into the program and they will be grades K-12 and ages 5-18. The New York City Office of Food and Nutrition Services team will invite individual schools to participate and for those who opt in, a virtual and in person training will be provided for both the administrators and food service teams at all schools. The study team will be onsite to administer the consumption measurements and the taste tests. School administrators and food service staff will be provided an informational training that will include a Power Point presentation describing the pilot program, detailing the taste test, as well as safety measures for those with allergies. Principals will have a notification letter for parents as well as a Frequently Asked Question document about the pilot and soymilk. Schools will also be provided promotional fliers and stickers to share with students upon their discretion. To assess and/or address any soy milk allergies during the taste testing: Students often submit an allergy/504 plan or a dietary accommodation request if they have an allergy, and therefore we will be including both the school nurse (if applicable) and cafeteria manager in the pilot training so we can ensure all students who have a documented allergy are notified they cannot partake in the taste test. We will also provide training on avoiding students with allergies in our training. Nurses will be invited to the training and we will ensure that there is uniform communication across all channels needed prior to taste test.